Hi @natman. In my opinion they are very good shaving soaps, but not top soaps, like for example Catie's Bubbles or Barrister & Mann, for mention a couple of them. And in my particular case, my skin feels very dry after the shave with this soap, in spite of they contain Shea butter.
I think this is one of the things that make funny this hobby: many times, same gear make different feelings in each person.Interestingly B&M make my skin feel dry after using it but not the NSS which I consider to be top drawer. As ever with skin and water differences YMMV - thankfully samples are available.