Name the top four, and ONLY four!

[Driftwood]

That's only three?

4 is not mandatory

 

[Paul L]

Is Noble Otter a hard soap? I thought it was a 'modern' shaving soap and closer to a croap like consistency.

Noble Otter isn't a croap

Wickham is a soft soap and so too is NO so we can’t count those. Same goes for Stirling.

Soft? Nah, it's hard - just not triple milled

 

[alfie5542]

Saponificio Varesino
Martin de Candre
Floris 89
Tabac

 

[Blademonkey]

Valobra
MWF
MdC
Cyril R Salter


Paul.

 

[donnie_arko]

Valobra
MWF
MdC
Cyril R Salter


Paul.

Believe in the Fat and the Fat will believe in you.

 

[Gairdner]

Believe in the Fat and the Fat will believe in you.

Amen brother, amen. All hail the Fat!

 

[Crossan]

MDC
MWF
Noble Otter
B&M (Omnibus)

This was an entertaining exercise, actually put some thought into it and these are the only ones I would buy again and again. Though now I'm questioning the mountain of alt supplier soaps sat in the wings!

 

[Bogeyman]

And nary one Briton has mentioned Yardley.

 

[Gairdner]

And nary one Briton has mentioned Yardley.

This Briton had nary the chance to try it, alas.

 

[Bogeyman]

This Briton had nary the chance to try it, alas.

It's extinct, but those who've used it say it was the best......especially the Black version.

 

[pjgh]

It's extinct, but those who've used it say it was the best......especially the Black version.

Not as good as Coty.

 

[culcreuch]

1. MWF
2. Cyril R Salter
3. Culmak (Modern)
4. D.R. Harris

Interestingly enough..........with the exception of MWF.....I believe the others are produced by the same company!

 

[donnie_arko]

1. MWF
2. Cyril R Salter
3. Culmak (Modern)
4. D.R. Harris

Interestingly enough..........with the exception of MWF.....I believe the others are produced by the same company!

The modern Culmak seems to go under the radar, not many seem to use it. I've seen it in a few chemists, I should pick one up at one point.

 

[culcreuch]

I should pick one up at one point.

I really like it. It performs well for me

 

[mrasparini]

1. Martin de Candre
2. Mitchell's
3. Cyril Salter
4. Arko

From 1 to 4 it's like from Earth to Neptune

 

[TobyC]

1. Martin de Candre
2. Mitchell's
3. Cyril Salter
4. Arko

From 1 to 4 it's like from Earth to Neptune

I can't afford the Martin de Candre, but the others look good.