Clinique post shave healer and soother are quite similar I use both but prefer the soother. I also like to keep it in the fridge so that it goes on cold. If you go to or are near Harrods they dish out samples which is a good way to try a few. Definitely try out Kiehls musk pricey but great scent. Also if you go for clinique I would get the facial scrub, shave cream and post shave soother it's a brilliant trio to use in succession by far the best for skin care that I've tried. I found Kiehls more greasy (initially) than clinique which is more milk like in consistency