I have tested P&B against OSP on separate cheeks for the last two days. Same razor and brush. I find that P&B does provide more cushion, slickness I find to be fairly consistent. The residual slickness after the face is washed is apparent with both products. Scent wise P&B is definitely stronger from what I own and the lack of sweet lime much appreciated! The bouquet also develops throughout the shave, similar to a high end aftershave, I am wondering where Kerry gets his scent profiles from! As a tester I wasn't keen on several scents provided, however, within the soap it is brilliant!
So from tomorrow we will be continuing with a new soap, I'll be dropping out as I'm away and will be taking high menthol soaps with me. So anyone interested in taking it forward next week step forward