Closed 'Complete' Pass Around - Carsons Apothecary 5 Star Shaving Formula

[globalm]

Thanks for your thoughts / review Paul.

Another thumbs-up then...

Definite Thumbs-up and thank you for the opportunity to try this.

Do you have experience of the other scents? This one would not be my first choice and I don't care for mint either. How are the others?

 

[Nico1970]

Paul, I also have Arabian Pomegranate, Sheikh's Musk and Sir Nelson's Florist!

My favourite is Sir Nelson's. When I return tonight, I'll give you my description of the scents.

Suffice it to say, they are invariably all fantastic performers.

 

[Nico1970]

Now, let me see...

Sir Nelson's Florist - Vetiver, patchouli, woodspice
Arabian Pomegranate - Pomegranate, musk, plum
Sheikh's Musk - Musk, patchouli

If you are not overly fussed on the Exotic Oud scent, I would give the Sheikh's Must a miss.

I haven't yet tried Amber 54 or Mr Carsons' Tea though, so you might find something there too.

 

[AlexNoodles]

Missed this thread altogether, please could I still be added to the list if pos?

 

[Nico1970]

Sure Alex, you're now on the list.

1. SeanC
2. Fly3k
3. Globalm*
4. AndyMc133
5. AlexNoodles

*Currently with

 

[Bechet]

Are they all runny slops, Nico, or just Exotic Oud?

 

[AlexNoodles]

Sure Alex, you're now on the list.

1. SeanC
2. Fly3k
3. Globalm*
4. AndyMc133
5. AlexNoodles

*Currently with

excellent!

 

[Nico1970]

Are they all runny slops, Nico, or just Exotic Oud?

Yeah, they're pretty much all similar levels of gloopiness Carl. I would say Arabian Pomegranate is a bit thicker than Sheikh's Musk and Sir Nelson's is the most runny of all.

Need to be careful opening them...

 

[Bechet]

Thanks! I'm fairly sure I wouldn't buy any more of them because of the gloopiness, even though the one I have performs well.

 

[AlexNoodles]

Thanks! I'm fairly sure I wouldn't buy any more of them because of the gloopiness, even though the one I have performs well.

fascinating! I am trying to work out how the brush/soap contact of all of a good 10 seconds can put someone off?
Guess I'll find out when it lands

 

[Bechet]

You miss the point, Alex. Open the tub a bit lopsided and you'll get it. Keep it dead level for an age to avoid the lid dripping on you, the floor, towel or whatever.

 

[globalm]

Andy

Did you receive this ok? What d'you think?

I've now bought a tub of Mr Carsons Tea. It is more sweet citrus than sharp Bergamot and is short of tea scent but it is very nice. Again, it smells very edible and one could imagine taking a spoon to it. Best not.

 

[Nico1970]

I haven't (yet!) tried Mr Carsons' Tea - presumably, it is still an exceptional performer Paul?

 

[AndyMc133]

Yeah I have the Carsons Apothecary very good soap as said before very liquid but lovely scent

Waiting for pm with address to pass on to

 

[Nico1970]

1. SeanC
2. Fly3k
3. Globalm
4. AndyMc133*
5. AlexNoodles

*Currently with

 

[AlexNoodles]

PM sent