For top trumps on the healing stakes I'd say the best I've ever tried was Zirh Sooth but it comes with a heft price tag and does go on a bit greasy.
2nd place would go to TOBS Mr Taylor Balm (misnomer really cos its more of a gel) works well, however I need to use quite a lot of it to get the desired effect but YMMV.
For the soothing quality vs price battle I'd go with Boots ASB but on the opposite to the TOBS I use little of the boots product as too much will make you feel greasy however the right amount leaves a very nice feeling on my face. To combat the greasyness splash some AS or cologne into it and mix it together before it hits your face.
Wonderful