Sorry to revive an older thread, but I bought some Thayers Unscented Witch Hazel from the Successful Singing website (link in this thread).
I used it this morning, and found it to be fantastic. When it says unscented, it really is unscented. This will allow me to buy Colognes without having to buy a matching A/S. The Thayers really soothed the skin well too, so it is skin effective as well as cost effective. As far as Witch Hazels go, it is probably not the cheapest (£2.99 for 50ml), but you certainly don't need to apply much. I anticipate the bottle will last quite a while.
Also, I would certainly recommend the Successful Singing site. I ordered on Sunday, and the package arrived this morning. Considering it was a Bank Holiday weekend, this is a quick turnaround. The invoice was hand-signed by a lady called Helen, and a free writing pen was included (a basic pen with the company logo, but a very nice little extra).