I have both and the AV is more cooling but both are great in this weather. I broke out the La Toja AS today, it has a nice summery scent and is quite nice on your skin.
Do you find you have a winter and a summer set of shaving creams and AS and colognes? I definitely find my tastes change toward the summer, living in Scotland it can got from 20 degrees one day and 10 the next and I even notice it on these days, the colder ones I wear more deep scents and the warm days it is the more flowery or lighter smells, I wonder why this is? I mean why not the deep scents in the summer? is it the feeling of coolness from the lighter scents?
Strange but true.