Just got a puck. Will give it a whirl for a bit and will report back. I have ultra-dry skin so this should be a good test. If it fails the test, you'll soon see it on the BST forum
Interesting. Tried the cade and it has no smell at all! Spoke to a sales lady in a L' Occitane shop and she told me that after a while the smell goes, but as I got it new, they would change it in store for me for free. Not sure I want to do that (bit of a trek to go back to the store) but nonetheless, seems like a pointless puck now...