Nanny's ice and a slice is next on my list to try, but I have a few soaps / creams to get through. I think like many others, I bought loads of creams at first because they seem easier to get started with but over time I've switched to soaps and face lathering. As a result, I have a few creams that simply don't make it into my daily rotation and therefore they will end up on the won't buy list, even though they might be good products.
So: will buy again -
Proraso Green Soap
DR Harris Marlborough soap (and aftershave, and cologne...)
Speick Cream
Won't buy again:
DR Harris Arlington cream (don't much like the smell)
Bluebeard's revenge cream
Neal's Yard Soap
Ingrams cream
Palmolive soap (I know it's cheap and performs well, but I enjoy other stuff more)
Also, not soap or cream but here are a few others:
DR Harris Marlborough aftershave - will buy again
TOBS Mr Taylor's Gentleman's Aftershave - cracking aftershave, but the smell doesn't really win me over so won't buy again, but will try their other stuff
Speick Aftershave - it's great but I've overused it so am bored of the smell. Will buy at some stage in the future but not imminently
Steve's Bay Rum - excellent aftershave that I will likely buy again
Alum - I used religiously at first, but having shattered a block I've not missed it so will probably not buy again
Blue Beard's Balm - won't buy again - it's OK but doesn't moisturise enough for me (I have quite dry skin and need something creamier)
L'Oreal Men Expert Hydrating Balm - won't buy. It's OK, but stings when applied and leaves a greasy feeling
Boots No. 7 Balm - have bought many times. At £8 a tube it's not the cheapest, but it suits me down to the ground!