British artisan soap is so good;
Overall P&B wins for me great scents & exemplary performance.
OSP is maybe a touch slicker, I get whiffs of the tallow.
Nannies, best scents of them all (to me).
The tallow soaps are just a whisker in front performance wise, there are tallow soaps available now from NSS, Ive had a tester sample & will be definately buying when I come to replace one of my signature soaps.
Wickhams, sooo easy to lather.
For me the easiest to use, any brush; dry/wet loaded, bowl or face lather.
Doesn't matter, you will get a great shave.
Haven't found a scent the sets me on fire, however, not tried any of the 1912 range.
Just my 2p-worth