Like Shrink I use a splash now rather than balms, but having said that T+H 1805 is a very nice balm. In fact they sell a test pack so that you can get ideas of what they're all like. I used Body Shop Kistna for a while too, that's very fruity and fresh smelling. Cheap too.
Some splashes that I use:
Ogalalla bay rum original. Not bad, sweet for a bay rum and can get slightly sickly after a while.
Ogalalla bay rum limes and peppercorns. Very nice and fresh.
Caldey Island lavender. Very pleasant indeed, summery and floral.
TOBS bay rum. Nice, very spicy, but no longevity. 5 minutes later, it's gone.
Barbershop Bay Rum. Complex and very appealing indeed, and cheap to buy.
I'll quite often use an EDT instead, my favourite so far is Crabtree and Evelyn's West Indian Limes.