Gents, please.. Brut is Brut, Clubman is Clubman and they are both inexpensive, if anyone really interested in any of them just buy it and decide on your own. Whether you may like it or not it is your own affair, you may find it similar to another cologne or not.
This discussion is pointless, like the other discussion on the soaps forum about MWF, you may like it or not. You like it, whether you can lather or not then good, you can't get a good lather then bin it or pif it or chuck it and move on.