I'm posting here as a lead-on from the August 2016 Acquisitions thread, in order to give some first impressions of my newly-acquired Hone 15a.
Firstly, I chose the 100mm long handle version, as I prefer long handles. I've also decided that I like a long handle on a lightweight (in this case, aluminium) razor, as I feel I have better control over it. Obviously, it's a bit heavier than the short handle option, but I couldn't say how much.
For a first go, I'm using a Feather blade, Wickham's Club Cola, and dishing up lather with a Plisson synth. I decided on a WTG, XTG and touch-up approach. The usual YMMV qualifications apply.
- Compared to the brass version, the 15a is a fraction of the weight and is therefore a lot easier to manipulate (or "throw around"). It gets into some of the more awkward spots a tad more easily.
- Whilst the best working angle is pretty much the same for both, I found it easier to hit it quickly with the 15a. I think this is because of the lightweight responsiveness, combined with a certain amount of tactile and audible feedback. These are transmitted through the 15a, far better than the heavier, "absorbing" 15.
- My impression is that the 15a is very slightly more aggressive than the 15, in which I have also used a Feather. This might possibly be so because there is less concern about control with the lighter razor, and/or the lightness encourages a bit more pressure.
- As with the 15, with this blade and a good soap, the end-result is a very smooth and irritation-free shave. I do have the impression that the 15a is somehow a little bit more "efficient".
- Of course, both razors are beautifully made, and cover the blade tabs; something I really like. Mine is the black model, which, if other black razors are anything to go by, will need more cleaning to keep it clear of soap residues and white marks. These don't bother me.
I like this razor very much. Provided that you don't mind a lighter instrument, teamed with a quality sharp blade (similar sort of thing to old Techs and other Gillettes), then it will likely suit you. Again, it's just my opinion, but I don't think that Derby, or some (most?) German and Indian blades would bring out the best in the 15a. I do have some of these, and may, in a spirit of self-sacrifice, see how they perform; but for the next two days, I'll enjoy the 15a with its present blade.
Downsides? I've now got another favourite razor, thus making my choices even more difficult. Life's tough like that.