I have used Trumpers, Taylors, T&H and DR Harris from the London sellers. I prefer Taylors. I usually use Coconut, also used Grapefruit, Mr Taylors, Peppermint. Their Sandalwood, smells horrible. I haven't tried those specific ones you're asking about. They smell ok, when I've checked them out in the store.
I've found I get a much better, thick, creamy and protective lather, compared to the other brands. I face and bowl lather depending on my mood in the morning. I tried Trumpers Eucris (currently) after not using their creams since using TOBS and still prefer the the later. Every now and then I fancy a change from TOBS, and can't wait to use up which ever cream it is I have.
The Palmolive stick, gives a great lather and shave, the smell isn't as nice as the others, but then it costs a fraction of the price.