Chiming in with my thoughts:
As with all of the RazoRock products I have tried in the past, getting this to lather was easy. A bit of water certainly helped with this one though.
Slickness wasn't as good as some and the sharper blades highlighted some issues with cushion, but it wasn't bad.
My view on the fragrance changed over the course of the shaves as it all but disappeared. You'd get a whiff at the start, but even that was subtle, then it would disappear. Certainly not one for those who like a hit of scent.
I wonder if the request to leave it open to dry for as long as possible dampened the power. I do the same for all my soaps though. Not that what I could pick up was unpleasant. You do get the feeling it's the mud that is given centre stage and the scent is an afterthought.
Despite the Fuller's Earth, I didn't find it performed any better than other RR products or provided significantly improved post shave feel. It didn't blow me away compared to other products either. The results of my shaves were quite varied, with none really shining.
As ever with RR, good value and a solid performance, but nothing spectacular.
Full review here.