Both the cream and the shave stick are solid performers, but I think the stick produces a better shave overall. I don't bother to grate it as I prefer to face lather. The smell is: a) soapy; b) nostalgic, and that works for me on both counts as I like uncomplicated scents in my soaps and creams.
I remember asking my wife whether she could think of any use for the green plastic ring that holds the shave stick. Had I carried out her suggestion, I would now be singing soprano in the local choir.