I like this thread because I was looking for an Old Spice alternative last year and I'm still interested, so I found the suggestions here really helpful and I'll definitely be looking into some purchases...my first shaving stuff of the year...and I was doing so well on my planned 'Dry 2021'


.
In my search a few months ago I did track down some of the made-in-India so called 'Original' scent Old Spice cream in a tube and it wasn't at all bad. It did remind me of the 'proper' Shulton shaving cream my dad used to use when I was a kid, so three little tubes for a few quid was worth it.
Here's a pic that I took at the time:
Note: all the other stuff around the tube is just vintage stuff that's not available any more...but the pre-electric, talc and splash all have original Shulton contents and I just like to smell them now and then. Great as a way of comparing the proper stuff with alternatives.

