Bay Rum Addicts

Personally, bay rum leaves me flat. After all, who want to smell like something they eat? That said, the aforementioned Krampert's is is pretty much universally acclaimed to be the most potent of the lot.
Different type of Bay! Bay Rum is from West Indies Bay and not culinary Bay trees. The former is actually toxic in high enough quantities (when eaten/drunk). Edit: I know one of the derivatives of West Indies Bay used is pimenta racemosa.
 

From Wikipedia. I did not know that. It still stinks.