@Roy I’ve only been around here a short while, so wouldn’t consider myself qualified to offer any insights or comments on the question you posed.
I succumbed in a moment of weakness when I saw a Captains Choice Obsidian Copper shaving bowl for sale on the Bay. For some dumb reason my finger was inexplicably drawn to the buy it now button and I’ve been using it for a week or so, I try to hide it from the cat, as he thinks he’s going to get his chow with full table cloth and waiter service with it.
It’s a bit daft when you consider I’m a face latherer BUT, I enjoy the process of mixing up a thick creamy base in the cat bowl and using that as the starter mix to make more on my face. Just from my own experience, I can say I don’t have buyers remorse - though the credit card bill hasn’t arrived as yet, so only time will tell.
The good thing about the bowl, is that it sits nicely in my sink of hot water and keeps the contents nice and warm as I’m having my shave.
I guess I should have prefaced this by saying my shaving journey started closer to 50 years ago, so I’m at a stage where if I want to try something new in this recently found enjoyable DE shaving experience, then I’m going to just go for it.
Good luck with your deliberations.