Their donkey milk which I'm sures a tallow base is excellent but not a big fan of their scents I tend to go with barrister and Mann like Wickhams too
+1 on the SV, Eufros I've never tried but some of there scents are very appealing to meWickhams have some seriously excellent scents - I have six and I haven't yet come across any that aren't anything from really good to wonderful. The whole range is good, which is unusual except for other favourites of mine like Eufros and SV.
I tried most of the WK range and the new formula definitively stepped up the game, I think it is still behind Excelsior base from B&M but only slightly! I agree some WK scents arent that great, but in general scents are so subjective that it doesn't bother me a few WK scents are masterpieces, same as some of B&Ms or A&Es.
IMO A&E with their pricing give the best value for money