Let's wind back a bit first and start with an introduction.
Welcome to TSR! I'm Boycie83 and I live in the wonderful county of Devon in the UK. Who do we have the pleasure of talking to as the OP?
Current top 5 aftershaves in no particular order:
Floïd Vigaroso - performance and cooling
Proraso Red - performance
RazoRock XXX - scent (makes me want to mount myself)
Williams A/V - a good balance of everything
TGS Abysso - see XXX above
One of these is likely to be dethroned once I've tried a splash from
@BrianH though