The tins let you try a lot of scents before you buy a larger bottle. A little goes a long way and the performance is 1st class. Lots of members use them (lots don’t too) but the balms and aftershaves are outstanding.
Other balms I use are Proraso - green, white and grey/blue. These are good too.
I also occasionally use Boots Freshwood which is a good scent for this cold weather.
Nivea too - sensitive aftershave balm and 2 Phase. The 2 Phase gives a really slick finish.