Gillette silver blue Vs. Gillette platinum

Messages
291
For those that have tried both how do these blades stack up against each other? I don't use too many different DE blades, in fact i mostly stick to Feather with the occasional GSB as these are the only blades that i consistently get good comfortable shave from.

So for those that need or prefer a super sharp blade how to the platinum's compare to others in that vein?

Thanks.
 
For those that have tried both how do these blades stack up against each other? I don't use too many different DE blades, in fact i mostly stick to Feather with the occasional GSB as these are the only blades that i consistently get good comfortable shave from.

So for those that need or prefer a super sharp blade how to the platinum's compare to others in that vein?

Thanks.

I've tried both blades and they are both excellent but I think they are quite different to each other.

The GSB is a very sharp blade, and fairly smooth at the time, but I wouldn't say it's the most forgiving blade out there.

The GP isn't as sharp but is very smooth and I'd describe it as being not as sharp as the GSB. Even though the blade can bite, I'd put it as being a little more forgiving to use.

If you already use the GSB and want another Gillette blade that's around as sharp but a little different I'd recommend Gillette 7 O'Clock Yellow/Black, Permasharp SS, Nacet etc.

Blades are a very YMMV so my observations might not be in line with the ones of others, but generally it's difficult to go wrong with any of Gillette's modern blades.
 
I've tried both blades and they are both excellent but I think they are quite different to each other.

The GSB is a very sharp blade, and fairly smooth at the time, but I wouldn't say it's the most forgiving blade out there.

The GP isn't as sharp but is very smooth and I'd describe it as being not as sharp as the GSB. Even though the blade can bite, I'd put it as being a little more forgiving to use.

If you already use the GSB and want another Gillette blade that's around as sharp but a little different I'd recommend Gillette 7 O'Clock Yellow/Black, Permasharp SS, Nacet etc.

Blades are a very YMMV so my observations might not be in line with the ones of others, but generally it's difficult to go wrong with any of Gillette's modern blades.


Thanks, of those that you mention i didn't get on with the 7 o'clock yellows, and didn't feel that the Nacet's offered anything over the GSB's just a little less smooth.

I think i'll try a tuck of the Platinum's and a tuck of the Permasharps next time i put an order in.

Thanks.
 
Thanks, of those that you mention i didn't get on with the 7 o'clock yellows, and didn't feel that the Nacet's offered anything over the GSB's just a little less smooth.

I think i'll try a tuck of the Platinum's and a tuck of the Permasharps next time i put an order in.

Thanks.
For what it's worth my opinion is that all of these blades can shave you as well as the others. Blade choice makes very little difference. I did not enjoy the feel of GSB but Nacets and Yellows I use regularly. I say use what you want haha
 
I've used both, back to back and I concur that the GSB's are a notch sharper. The Platinums are sharp and forgiving, a decent blade, if you favour an aggressive razor they might be just the job.

Personally I favour very mild razors, I use settings 1-3 on a vintage adjustable and favour very sharp blades like Lab Blues, Medical Preps and Polsilvers SI. If you decide you like Platinums I have 700 which I'd be happy to move on at a 'below bulk purchase' rate.

Bazz, having re read your post, I would try Lab Blues or Medical Preps from Connaught. Med Preps are as sharp as Feather and very smooth and consistant - also not too expensive in bulk.
 
Last edited:
I've tried both blades and they are both excellent but I think they are quite different to each other.

The GSB is a very sharp blade, and fairly smooth at the time, but I wouldn't say it's the most forgiving blade out there.

The GP isn't as sharp but is very smooth and I'd describe it as being not as sharp as the GSB. Even though the blade can bite, I'd put it as being a little more forgiving to use.

If you already use the GSB and want another Gillette blade that's around as sharp but a little different I'd recommend Gillette 7 O'Clock Yellow/Black, Permasharp SS, Nacet etc.

Blades are a very YMMV so my observations might not be in line with the ones of others, but generally it's difficult to go wrong with any of Gillette's modern blades.
Spot on assessment +1
 
A blade is a blade, as long as it's not dull or banged up. Get someone else to put blades in your razor and I bet you couldn't identify them without looking.
Even though i have only been using DE's for about 6 months, i'm sure i can identify all of the blades that i have tried in that time.
The blade is the most important part of my shave.
 
Even though i have only been using DE's for about 6 months, i'm sure i can identify all of the blades that i have tried in that time.
The blade is the most important part of my shave.

That will change, a year from now the blade won't matter as much. Blade angle, good lather, and your skin are what matters, your skin will adapt to shaving close, especially if you shave daily.
 
That will change, a year from now the blade won't matter as much. Blade angle, good lather, and your skin are what matters, your skin will adapt to shaving close, especially if you shave daily.
I guess YMMV then - because I don't believe that all blades feel the same on my skin, and in different razors. if they all do the same job for you, (that's) good - and you can probably save some bucks buying the cheapest out there
 
I guess YMMV then - because I don't believe that all blades feel the same on my skin, and in different razors. if they all do the same job for you, (that's) good - and you can probably save some bucks buying the cheapest out there


If you become more proficient the disparity between blades decreases greatly if your prep & technique improve as well. I won't lie to you and say everyone figures this out as they don't. As well, a good soap/cream helps also.
 
Was surprised with my first time trying a GSB. Not sharp at all, had to open my Merkur Progress up to 3.5 to get it close. Maybe just a dud blade or it's not the right combo with the Progress.

I've been using Gillette Nacets in my Merkur Futur and getting very nice close shaves. Yesterday I put in a new GSB in it and found it very irritating ATG and I was left with weepers in the moustache area. I'll give it another go to see if its second use is less rough. I know other people swear by GSB but as they say YMMV.
 
Back
Top Bottom