My finest Bay Rum splash so far is a cocktail I've called BOOBS:
1/3 Benjamins Bay Rum (without Pimento...)
1/3 Ogallala Bay Rum with Sandalwood and Peppercorns
1/3 Vintage Old Spice
A few drops of Bay oil
Splash of West Indian Rum
I use it everyday and it's a great aftershave without too much bite.
I'm also fiddling with a more complicated concoction for when this runs out, featuring the same Benjamins base but infused with Pimento, Green and Black Peppercorns, more WI Rum, Bay oil, Witch Hazel and Indian Old Spice with lime.