Which is better, Arlington or 4711 after shave lotions?

[Sir_eider]

Hi!

Some time ago I bought a pot of Arlington shaving cream and I like it much for this summer. Now I'm looking for an after shave with a strong, similar scent, and at first I thought in buying the same range after shave splash, but I have read that 4711 after shave (a lot cheaper) have a similar scent.

So, what do you think about both after shaves? It's Arlington splash worth the extra price comparing 4711? Which has a better, long-lasting scent?

Cheers!

 

[NotTheStig]

There are some similarities but I wouldn't have thought of comparing them. The 4711 cologne doesn't seem to last long although it is quite subtle so it may still be there and I don't notice it. It's a nice summery fragrance to have anyway.