My first shave with the erasmic stick was really good but in saying that it was either dark in my bathroom or a fluke as when I've used it since the lather just evaporates in front of my eyes. Shame really as I find the Palmolive dries my skin a but the Erasmic leaves it feeling great. Might try mashing them both together.
I have however, recently tried Arko which I personally think is the best of the bunch so far. Great lather and after care. It does have a strong lemonish pong but nothing I find off putting. Fairly cheap as well.