My favourite is (was?) TOBS "Shaving Shop" scenet. while typing this I thought to myself I need to buy some more, but it seems to have been discontinued? Does anybody know what happened to that? Similar in a way to Eton College, except lighter, fresher and less of a zesty scent.
Close second for me is Musgo Real "Lime Basil". Cream quality up there with the 3 T's and the scent rings the same sort of bells that TOBS Shaving Shop did. A light and fresh fragrance. Smells understated and subtle when in use but lingers nicely on the skin. In my head, a real old school barber shop scent.
Honourable mentions to GFT Eucris and GFT Violet. Eucris for the ultimate luxury gentleman shave and Violet is a perfect naturally floral scent. Well worth a shot, even if you dislike rose or lavender, violet may well be for you.