Sorry to revive such an old thread, but with all the new soap makers does anyone have new recommendations?
I also have sensitive skin, and the ones I've used are:
Vander hagen (but it's not great - I generally use just when traveling)
Ogallala Bay Rum Unscented (decent lather, but I'm just about done with the puck)
Soap Commander Integrity (I enjoy it, but I'd love a second great option).