The Shulton formulation of Old Spice was way before my time, so sadly I never got to try it. The P & G version is the only one I have ever known. I vividly remember the adverts from the 1980s, though, with the surfer riding the waves and that soaring, masculine music. Most of my friends used to take the piss out of Old Spice when I was younger, but I always defended it. I could never have realised back then that I would end up wearing it myself when I was older. The modern formulation is as weak as cats' piss, but it still has a special place in my heart. Everyone's grandfather used to have a bottle of it in their bathroom cabinet, I am sure.